The future of our thoroughbred industry is now in the hands of the Federal Court and we can only hope that common sense prevails.
The long-awaited controversial case aimed at lifting the ban on artificial insemination for racehorse breeding began today.
The challenge was brought by Bruce McHugh, a former bookmaker and former Sydney Turf Club Chairman.
He argues AI is a restraint of trade that he wants overturned so that he can (according to the Sydney Morning Herald) breed horses at Tamworth and compete for major prize pools in big races.
The case is being strongly opposed by the TBA, Australian Racing Board and Australian Stud Book, fighting to maintain Australia’s international reputation and integrity.
The problem is that the International Stud Book only accepts horses that have been conceived naturally as being eligible to race and breed.
Therefore, if AI is introduced in Australia our horses eligiblity at international races and sales will be called into question.
“Breeders are not opposed to AI,” said TBA CEO, Peter McGauran.
“The proponents are perfectly free to set up their own AI breeding and racing industry, but to mix it with the thoroughbred breed which is defined by natural coverings is to damage, if not destroy, our international market place in racing and breeding.
“You can’t unscramble the omlete.”
Legal costs could climb as high as $10 million, however when you consider Australia exports around 2500 horses to the tune of $200 million annually, it will hopefully be money well spent in guarding our future.
“If Australia goes unilaterally and is the only country in the world to introduce AI, then we would be excluded from the major jurisdications such as the UK, France, the US and most of Asia,” said Mr McGauran.
It goes without saying it would cripple our industry.
“It would be insane to do it,” said Mr McGauran.
The case is set to run until October 16 before Judge Alan Robertson, with testimony from over 40 witnesses.
Unfortunately we will have to wait until next year before the decision is handed down.
|